Team sports beat solo exercise for men’s mental health

You’re standing at the gym entrance on a Tuesday evening. Do you head to the basketball court where guys are calling for players? Or do you grab those headphones and hit the treadmill alone? For millions of men, this choice happens daily. And here’s what might surprise you: the research shows your decision could dramatically impact your mental health. A massive study of 1.2 million Americans found that men who played team sports had 22% fewer bad mental health days than those who didn’t exercise at all.

The Brotherhood Factor: Why Teams Win for Mental Health

NBA star Kevin Love puts it perfectly: “Mental health isn’t just an athlete thing. What you do for a living doesn’t have to define who you are. This is an everyone thing. No matter what our circumstances, we’re all carrying around things that hurt — and they can hurt us if we keep them buried inside.”

Love’s words hit at something crucial. Men often struggle with isolation. We’re taught to be self-reliant. Strong. Independent. But when it comes to mental health, going it alone isn’t always the answer.

Team sports create something solo exercise can’t: built-in social connection. When you’re part of a basketball team, softball league, or soccer club, you’re not just moving your body. You’re building relationships. Sharing experiences. Creating a support network that extends beyond the game.

The Science Is Clear: Teams Take the Lead

The research tells a compelling story. That landmark study in The Lancet Psychiatry examined over 1.2 million Americans and found individuals who exercised experienced 43% fewer days of poor mental health than those who didn’t exercise at all. But here’s the kicker: team sports delivered the biggest mental health benefits.

Team sports participants reported 22.3% fewer bad mental health days than non-exercisers, followed by cycling (21.6% reduction) and gym activities (20.1% reduction). Even walking showed benefits, but team sports were the clear winner.

Additional research backs this up. A study published in PMC found that individual sport athletes were more likely to carry diagnoses of anxiety or depression compared to team sport athletes. Students who did group physical activity had better mental health than those who exercised alone and were nearly twice as physically active.

Want more proof? Research shows the optimal frequency is 45 minutes of exercise, 3-5 days per week. This aligns perfectly with most recreational sports leagues.

Why Teams Work Better for Your Brain

Think about what happens in team sports versus solo exercise:

Team Sports Create:

Social accountability (harder to skip when teammates depend on you)
Shared goals and celebrations
Natural stress relief through camaraderie
Leadership opportunities
Built-in emotional support

Solo Exercise Offers:

Complete control over pace and intensity
Flexibility in scheduling
Personal meditation time
Self-reliance building
No pressure from others

Both have value. But for many men, the social element of team sports provides mental health benefits that solo exercise simply can’t match.

Solo Exercise: When Going Alone Works

Don’t write off solo exercise entirely. Recent research shows that the “why” behind your exercise matters as much as the exercise itself. If you’re running because you love the mental clarity, that’s different than running because you feel obligated.

Solo exercise works best when you:

Crave quiet thinking time
Have unpredictable schedules
Prefer setting your own pace
Use movement for stress relief
Want to challenge personal limits

Some men find their mental health sweet spot in activities like:

Trail running or hiking
Swimming laps
Weightlifting with music
Cycling scenic routes
Rock climbing

The key is choosing activities that feel rewarding, not punishing.

Take Action: Find Your Mental Health Sweet Spot

Ready to optimize your exercise for better mental health? Here are five strategies to try:

1. Start with One Team Activity Per Week

Join a recreational league, pickup basketball game, or hiking group. Research shows even one team activity session provides measurable benefits. Start small and build from there.

2. Mix Team and Solo Exercise

You don’t have to choose just one. Try this weekly split:

2 team sport sessions (basketball, softball, soccer)
2 solo activities (running, weightlifting, swimming)
1 rest or light activity day

3. Focus on Fun Over Fitness

Studies show that enjoying your chosen sport contributes significantly to mental health benefits. Pick activities you actually look forward to, not ones you think you “should” do.

4. Build Your Exercise Community

Even if you prefer solo exercise, find ways to add social elements:

Join a running club
Find a workout partner
Use fitness apps with social features
Participate in local fitness events

5. Track Your Mental Health Impact

Notice how different exercises affect your mood, energy, and stress levels. What makes you feel most energized? Most calm? Most confident? Use this data to guide your choices.

Try This Today

Don’t wait until Monday to start. Here’s your immediate action plan:

Right now: Text three friends and ask who wants to shoot hoops, play tennis, or join a softball league this week.

This week: Try one new team-based activity, even if it’s just joining a pickup game at your local gym.

This month: Sign up for one recreational sports league or regular group fitness class.

Remember: As Kevin Love reminds us, “Mental health is an invisible thing, but it touches all of us at some point or another.” The choice between team sports and solo exercise isn’t just about fitness. It’s about finding the approach that best supports your mental well-being.

The Bottom Line

Both team sports and solo exercise can boost your mental health. But if you’re struggling with isolation, stress, or feeling disconnected, team sports might be your secret weapon. The research is clear: the combination of physical activity and social connection creates a powerful one-two punch for mental wellness.

Tomorrow, we’ll explore how to balance your professional goals with mental health by managing career pressure effectively.

🏃 Move your body, lift your mood

Resources

Dale

See Full Bio