Difficult Conversations: Talking Mental Health with Family

The Silent Struggle

Picture this: It’s Sunday dinner. Your brother seems different lately—quieter, distant. Your dad’s been more irritable than usual. But nobody talks about it. Sound familiar? Research shows that 40% of men won’t discuss their mental health with close friends, family, or a medical professional. For many men, starting these conversations feels like admitting weakness. But here’s the truth: talking about mental health isn’t weakness—it’s wisdom.

Breaking Down the Walls

The Reality Men Face

Men face unique barriers when it comes to mental health conversations. Studies reveal that many men avoid seeking professional mental health services due to feelings of embarrassment or fear of being perceived as weak. This isn’t just about stubbornness. Research shows men often compartmentalize their relationships, having different kinds of social connections with men versus women. They might talk sports with their brothers but struggle to share their deepest fears.

The numbers tell a sobering story. Only 52% of Americans say they are extremely or very comfortable talking about their mental health with an immediate family member. For men, these numbers drop even lower. Yet the same research shows that 79% of married or partnered Americans are extremely or very comfortable talking about their mental health with their spouse or partner—proving that close relationships can be safe havens for these conversations.

What Science Tells Us

Recent research from the National Institutes of Health reveals fascinating insights about men’s communication patterns. Men who compartmentalize their relationships often rely on women in private for confiding and emotional support, while maintaining a more stoic facade with other men. This creates an invisible struggle where men want to connect but don’t know how.

Another groundbreaking study found that media-based campaigns targeting male help-seeking show promise when messaging aligns with male communication preferences. This suggests that how we talk matters as much as what we say.

A Christian Perspective on Healing

From a Christian standpoint, mental health conversations aren’t separate from our faith—they’re deeply connected to it. Biblical teaching and Jesus himself often spoke about our emotions, thoughts, actions, and desires, with Jesus claiming that following Him would begin a process of transforming how people think, feel, and act.

The Gospel offers a framework for understanding mental health struggles. A truly gospel-centered conversation about mental health will wrestle with God’s creation, man’s fall, and God’s redemptive and restorative plan. This doesn’t mean prayer replaces professional help. Instead, it means we can approach mental health conversations knowing that God cares about our whole person—mind, body, and spirit.

Scripture reminds us to “bear one another’s burdens” (Galatians 6:2). Mental health struggles are burdens worth sharing. When families create space for these conversations, they’re living out biblical community.

Expert Insights

Dr. Zac Seidler, a leading researcher in men’s mental health, emphasizes that traditional masculine traits aren’t inherently problematic. The key is finding ways to honor men’s values while encouraging openness. Traits like mental toughness and a strong work ethic, commonly associated with traditional masculinity, can enhance resilience and coping strategies when integrated into therapeutic contexts.

Counseling professionals note that men often prefer to communicate about depression in ways that maintain their sense of control and agency. This means approaching conversations as collaborative problem-solving rather than emotional processing.

Taking Action: Five Strategies That Work

1. Start Side by Side

Some people feel more comfortable talking while doing an activity they enjoy, so the focus doesn’t feel entirely on them. Try talking while:

Working on a project together
Going for a walk or hike
Driving somewhere
Playing catch or shooting hoops

The shared activity takes pressure off direct eye contact and creates natural conversation flow.

2. Use “Guy-Friendly” Language

Research shows men respond better to certain communication approaches. Instead of saying:

“How are you feeling?” try “How are you handling things?”
“You seem depressed” try “You seem like you’re going through a tough time”
“Let’s talk about emotions” try “Let’s figure this out together”

Use words that keep the other person in charge, like ‘this worked for me, but it may not work for you. If it helps, good. If not, that’s okay, too. It’s your call.’

3. Share Your Own Struggles

Vulnerability breeds vulnerability. When you open up about your own mental health challenges, you give permission for others to do the same. Say things like:

“I’ve been struggling with anxiety lately”
“I went through something similar when…”
“I learned that getting help actually made me stronger”

4. Focus on Practical Solutions

Men often respond well to action-oriented conversations. After listening, offer concrete next steps:

“Would you like me to help you find a counselor?”
“What if we started working out together?”
“I found this resource that might help”

Try not to give advice: even when we have good intentions, giving advice can leave us taking ownership of the situation. Instead, ask questions that help them find their own solutions.

5. Make It Ongoing

Use regular check-ins, even if it’s just sending a text, as gentle reminders that you’re there for someone. Mental health conversations aren’t one-and-done. They require consistent, patient investment.

Try This Today

Pick one family member you’re concerned about. Send them a simple text: “Hey, thinking about you. How are you handling everything?” Don’t expect a deep response immediately. The goal is to plant a seed that says “I’m here when you’re ready.”

Alternatively, suggest a side-by-side activity for this week. “Want to help me with [project] on Saturday?” or “Feel like going for a walk after dinner?” Create the space, and let the conversation develop naturally.

The Path Forward

Mental health conversations with family aren’t about fixing people—they’re about loving them well. Sometimes the most powerful thing you can do is simply show up and listen. In a world where men often feel pressured to have all the answers, being present without judgment is revolutionary.

Remember: you don’t have to be a counselor to care. You just have to be human.

Tomorrow, we’ll explore “After a Suicide Attempt: Recovery and Prevention Strategies”—crucial information for supporting loved ones through their darkest moments and building hope for the future.

🤝 You’re not alone in this journey

Resources

Dale

See Full Bio